OwnAway

Guide

Should I hire a property manager? A worksheet for landlords with a few units

Updated

The question usually arrives at 11pm, after a tenant text. That is the wrong time to answer it. Here is how to answer it on a Sunday afternoon with a calculator, so that the next 11pm text is either handled by someone else or handled by a system you chose.

What a manager costs and what you get

  • Monthly fee: commonly 8–12% of collected rent for full service; sometimes a flat per-unit fee. On a $1,800 unit that is roughly $145–$215 a month, every month, whether anything happened or not.
  • Leasing fee: often half to a full month's rent each time a unit turns.
  • Maintenance markup: many managers add 10–20% to vendor invoices, or use in-house crews at their rates.
  • Renewal, inspection, setup, and early-termination fees vary; read the agreement.
  • In return: marketing, screening, leases, rent collection, maintenance coordination, tenant communication, and monthly statements. You become an investor rather than an operator.

The hours you are actually buying back

Track two weeks honestly. Most self-managing landlords find the time splits roughly like this: maintenance and tenant communication are the majority and the most disruptive (they arrive at random); rent collection is small if it is automated; leasing is large but happens once a year per unit. So the fee buys back mostly maintenance hours — and it buys them at a percentage of rent that does not fall when things are quiet.

Two-week log
Date · Unit · What (tenant text / vendor call / visit / paperwork) · Minutes · After 8pm or weekend? (y/n) · Could a system have handled it without me? (y/n)

Two numbers matter at the end: total hours a month, and the share that was maintenance and tenant communication. The first tells you what a manager's fee is worth per hour. The second tells you whether you need a full manager or just the maintenance half handled.

Three questions that decide it

  1. Do you want to stop being the decision-maker, or stop being the one interrupted? A manager removes both. If you actually like choosing the vendor and approving the spend, and it is the interruptions you resent, a full manager is more than you need.
  2. Is leasing a problem? If your units turn rarely and you can show them yourself, you are paying a leasing fee for nothing. If you are out of state or turning units every year, leasing is where a manager earns their fee.
  3. Would you keep the manager's vendors and prices? Many managers use their own crews with their own markups. If you have good vendors at good prices, a manager can cost you twice: the fee and the markup.

The middle option

For most landlords with a few units to a few dozen, the honest answer to the log is: the pain is maintenance and tenant communication, the rest is fine. That used to mean a full manager or nothing. It no longer does. A managed-maintenance service runs the whole loop — tenant intake, triage, your vendors, follow-up, the record — for a flat cost that does not scale with rent, and leaves leasing, screening, rent, and every decision with you.

Questions

At how many units does a property manager make sense?

There is no unit count; it is a time-and-distance question. A landlord with 20 local units and good vendors may never need one; a landlord with one unit three states away may need one immediately. Do the two-week log.

Can I hire a manager for maintenance only?

Some managers offer maintenance-only agreements, usually at a reduced percentage or flat fee. Managed-maintenance services built for that job are the newer alternative.